ABSTRACT: Differentiation between low and high ankle sprains is critical to delivering appropriate care. The classic mechanism for a low ankle sprain is inversion and plantar flexion. A history of ankle ligament injury predisposes to recurring sprains. The ankle anterior drawer test may be used to evaluate ligamentous instability. Plain radiographs of the foot and ankle may be indicated in a patient who has an acute ankle injury. Clinicians often use the Ottawa ankle rules to determine the need for radiographs. In the acute phase, the goals of treatment are to alleviate pain, reduce swelling, and protect the ankle from further injury. NSAIDs and rehabilitation are important components of management. Primary prevention may be possible with strengthening and balance programs. (J Musculoskel Med. 2008;25:438-443)
Ankle sprains are the most common musculoskeletal injury in athletes, accounting for 10% to 30% of sports injuries.1 Differentiation between low and high (syndesmotic) sprains is critical to delivering appropriate care to patients who sustain either injury.
An understanding of the anatomy and biomechanics of the ligaments that provide stability to the ankle and distal tibiofibular joint, as well as the risk factors for ankle sprains, is essential to performing a competent clinical evaluation. In most cases, applying this knowledge during the physical examination allows for an accurate diagnosis.
This 2-part article defines the salient points of clinical evaluation of ankle sprains to differentiate between low and high sprains and, as a result, provide patients with the most appropriate treatment. In this first part, we focus on low ankle sprains. The second part, to appear in a later issue of this journal, will discuss diagnosis and management of high ankle sprains.
BACKGROUND
Acute ankle injuries are especially common in persons who participate in basketball, racquet sports, gymnastics, volleyball, and soccer. 1-3 Athletes who compete at higher levels of play are at increased risk for ankle sprains4; they are the most common injury in college athletes, according to the National Collegiate Athletic Association Injury Surveillance Survey results, accounting for 15% of reported injuries. 5 Ligamentous injuries to the ankle are the most common injury regardless of the sport or exposure type (game or practice).1,5
The incidence of re-injury in athletes with ankle sprains is significantly higher than the incidence of first-time ankle sprains.6 Disability resulting from ankle sprains may be severe; 40% of patients experience dysfunction for as long as 6 months after the injury. In a Marchi and associates7 study, 23% of ankle sprains resulted in permanent sequelae over 12 years.
The cost of treating patients with ankle sprains is staggering. In 2003 alone, the direct medical cost of managing ankle sprains was more than $1 billion, according to US Consumer Products Safety Commission estimates.8
ANATOMY AND BIOMECHANICS
Both osseous congruity and ligaments confer stability to the ankle joint. Osseous congruity exists between the tibiotalar and distal tibiofibular joints.
